April 2004
Please refresh if you are not seeing a very current date and time.

8:33PM

May God's Will Be Done


Why We Won't Be Registering
Go to: Concern over the future of SETON CATHOLIC HIGH SCHOOL

One Family's Viewpoint



On March 25, 2004, Bishop Joseph F. Martino of the Diocese of Scranton met with 18 priests from the Pittston Deanery.

During this meeting, he presented the priests with a letter which the Bishop, or one of his representatives from the Catholic Schools Office of the Scranton Diocese, had composed. The Diocesean symbol was on the letterhead, but nowhere on the letter was Bishop Martino's name. Instead, the letter had the names of the 18 priests listed, in two columns and alphabetically by chronology, on the last page.

The letter was addressed to parents of students at two Catholic schools in the Region 7 (Pittston area) of Diocese of Scranton: St. John the Baptist Elementary School in Pittston, and Saint Mary's School, Avoca. In the body of the letter was the bombshell announcement that the two schools would be closing in June, and that parents should choose a new school for their children. The names of the four remaining schools in the Region 7 area were listed in the letter;

Saint Mary the Assumption School, Pittston
Sacred Heart School, Dupong
Wyoming Area Catholic School, Exeter
Holy Rosary School, Duryea

The priests were instructed by Bishop Joseph F. Martino (Auxilary Bishop Dougherty was also present) to copy the letter and send it out to the parents of the children of SJB and SMA. No discussion on the matter was held. Priests later informed parishoners that they were in "shock" that two schools so close together (approximately 2.5 miles) and with such a large, combined census - nearly 300 students - would be closed at one time.

The next day, on Friday, March 26, 2004, a meeting was held for faculty for the both schools. It was during this meeting that faculty and staff of the two schools learned, for the first time, that their two schools were closing.

Needless to say, there was shock, grief, and disbelief in that room. St. John the Baptist School's principal, Mr. Robert Kaluzavich, who has spent 39 of his 55 years as a student, teacher and principal at SJB, and who not only spends his days at the school but his nights coaching basketball, going to meetings, hadn't even been consulted about the possibility of a closing of his beloved school. A modest man, he would be the first to deny it, but "Mr. K', as the students have, for many years, affectionately called him, is, most definitely, one of the finest principals in any school system, Catholic or otherwise. His dedication to the school, and to Catholic values, is unquestioned. He did NOT deserved to be treated in the disrespectful way in which he was treated by both the Bishop and the Catholic Schools Office.

Word quickly spread about the school closings which, especially in the case of St. John the Baptist in Pittston, (St. Mary's had been having financial difficulty and enrollment decline for a few years) was totally unexpected. Children had already registered for the next school year at Saint John's only the previous month. Kindergarten registration and Open House was less then two weeks prior to the announcement by the Bishop that he wanted to close St. John the Baptist.

Parents from both schools immediately began to organize in an effort to prevent the closings and find out the facts. The result of that organization is this web site, and numerous rallies, prayer vigils, and organized protests in front of the Diocese of Scranton buildings. Media attention was also immediate and wide-spread, especially when it became known that many of the priests did NOT approve of the Bishop's plan to close the two schools, even though their names were listed on the letter composed by the Scranton Diocese.

Within two days of the announcement by Bishop Martino, he was approached by a large group (hundreds) of praying students and parents at Mount Carmel Church in Pittston, where he had come to attend a mens' "smoker".

Bishop Martino, reacting to resolve of the parents and students not to allow their schools to close, and to the television cameras and microphones waiting for him on the steps of the church, emerged from the social gathering after an hour. He addressed the crowd while standing on the steps of Mount Carmel and, while expressing sympathy for our "pain", made it clear that he would not reverse his decision. His reasoning was that closing the schools would save money.

Since that time, even during a closed door meeting where parents of SJB and SMA students presented an alternate plan whereby the two schools could merge into one large, strong school which would be about equal in savings to the Scranton Diocese as would closing the schools, Bishop Martino and his financial staff have reiterated that he will NOT reverse his decision. During the April 14 meeting in Scranton, the Bishop made it quite clear that he did not want to be known as a bishop who reversed a decision once it was made. No matter what.

The Diocese of Scranton has repeatedly denied a request by parents to push back registration at the four remaining schools until parents and students have answers to their many concerns and questions. The only concession given to parents regarding Registration is that it will not be housed at Seton Catholic High School in Pittston instead of at the four schools.

Concern Over the Future of Seton Catholic High School, Pittston

Seton Catholic High School is the ONLY Catholic High School between the Scranton Diocese headquarters and the Kingston/Wilkes-Barre area....a distance of approximately 19 miles. The two schools targeded to close, St. John the Baptist, Pittston, and St. Mary's, Avoca, are the main feeder schools for Seton Catholic. Traditionally, half of the enrollment of freshmen at Seton Catholic traditionally comes from SJB and SMA. Yet the Diocese has continued to deny that it is placing Seton Catholic in danger. Bishop Martino, who arrived in the Scranton Diocese only six months ago from the Philadelphia Diocese, and the Catholic Schools Office have insisted that closing the two grade schools will strengthen Seton Catholic High School and the Catholic education system in the Pittston area.

Unfortunately, that position by the Diocese and the Bishop does not bear out the facts.

The one remaining school within the Pittston city limits, if Bishop Martino does not reverse his decision to close SJB, is St. Mary's the Assumption School. St. Mary's Assumption not only has a nearly full school enrollment, thereby making it impossible for many of the SJB students to enroll in this school, but also has a strong tradition of having students matriculate and go on to Scranton Prep in Scranton and Bishop Hoban in Wilkes-Barre.

Saint John the Baptist School and Saint Mary's School have always promoted Seton Catholic High School in Pittston as the natural choice for high school for their eighth grade students.

The Diocese of Scranton Catholic Schools Office, reacting to the strong concern of parents for the future of Seton Catholic, has placed the responsibility for the future of Seton Catholic High School in Pittston in the hands of parents, stating that if parents enroll their children in the Pittston high school, it will not close.

This stance by the Diocese of Scranton, in closing Seton's two main feeder schools and expecting it to prosper, is analgous to cutting off the legs of Seton and expecting it to run the marathon.

The Four Remaining Catholic Schools

Parents who want their children to remain in the Catholic education system in the Pittston area of the Diocese of Scranton are now being rushed to enroll the children in one of four remaining schools. Two of the four school already have very limited spaces available for new students. School choice is, therefore, severely limited.

For example, there are 29 third grade students being displaced from St. John the Baptist and St. Mary's Avoca. St. Mary's the Assumption School already has an enrollment of 22 students in its fourth grade. That means there is only room for, at most, 3 more third grade students in St. Mary's Assumption.

The ideal class size is no more than 25 students- even in public schools.. (See Times Leader article, "CATHOLIC SCHOOL CLOSINGS COULD IMPACT PITTSTON AREA TAXPAYERS", of April 13, 2004. Dr. Frank Serino, Pittston area Superintendent, states that "up to 25 students make up the third-fourth- and fifth-grade classes in the Intermediate Center" and that adding more would necessitate building additional classrooms.)

Holy Rosary School in Duryea, which is nearly 3 miles from St. John the Baptist School, already has 26 students in the third grade! There is NO room, ideally speaking, for any third grade students from St. Mary's in Avoca and St. John the Baptist School in Pittston.

That leaves two schools for the 26 remaining third grade students (if 3 choose St. Mary's the Assumption, Pittston) at Wyoming Area Catholic in Exeter (over 3 miles away) and Sacred Heart, Dupont. Sacred Heart, Dupont, has only 10 students in the third grade. That means there is room for 15 - IF the students and parents of the displaced SJB and SMA students wanted to attend this school, which is a fine school, surely, but which has no cafeteria and no gym. ( St. John the Baptist has a wonderful gym AND cafeteria, with hot lunches!). That would mean 11 students of 26 students from SJB and SMA,who had not been admitted or chosen Sacred Heart, St. Mary's Assumption or Holy Rosary, would remain without a school!

Now we are down to one school- Wyoming Area Catholic. WAC is not in the Pittston area school district, and is a considerable distance for St. Mary's Avoca parents to drive. (It is also about 3-4 miles from Pittston and about 3 miles further for Avoca parents). WAC, which currently has 21 students in the third grade, ideally has room for only 4 third grade students of the 11 remaining students (if the other 18 did, indeed, choose Sacred Heart,Holy Rosary, or St. Mary's Assumption) being displaced from SJB and SMA. Under the nearly impossible circumstances that the first 18 students would truly choose St. Mary's Assumption, Holy Rosary, and Sacred Heart as their school choice, this would mean that, even with the spaces available at Wyoming Area Catholic, there would STILL be 7 current-third-grade students without a proper space in a Catholic school!!

11-4=7 students without a school.

Where are these 7 students from SJB and SMA to go?

No matter how the Diocese of Scranton and Bishop Joseph F. Martino try to gloss over the mess they have created with their proposed school closings, the facts remain that they have not thought this out correctly- or fairly.

Wyoming Area Catholic allegedly owes approximately $500,000.00 (yes, half a million) of the entire ONE MILLION dollar debt cited by Bishop Martino by the ALL of the Pittston parishes in the Scranton Diocese. The school, while beautiful and well-staffed, is quite a distance away for nearly all the displaed SJB and SMA students. Sacred Heart, another nice school, has no cafeteria, and no gym. Holy Rosary and St. Mary's Assumption are already just about full.

And, no matter how you size up this situation with the two school closings, there are going to be a LOT of kids who are just going to end up in the public school system not by CHOICE, but because they were FORCED to go there by Bishop Martino and the Catholic Schools Office of the Scranton Diocese. And why will they be forced to go to public schools? Because of money.

Certainly, money has to be a consideration in this situation. If the Diocese of Scranton is in debt to the tune of a total of 11 million dollars, and the Pittston diocese in in debt for 1 million dollars, as the Bishop states, something can and should be done SOMEWHERE in the Diocesean budget. But why hurt the kids? Where exactly was the 11 million dollars spent? Certainly not all -or even most - on Catholic education in the Pittston area. And expecially NOT at St. John the Baptist School in Pittston.

There should be a full accounting of the money by the Diocese if the money situation is being used as an excuse to hurt these children. And these children are really being hurt in a way that may effect them - and their faith in the Catholic Church - for a long time to come. Doesn't that concern the Bishop and the Diocese of Scranton? Has the Scranton Diocese, and Bishop Martino, explored EVERY avenue, tightened EVERY belt, before resorting to the closure of two very fine Catholic schools AND the traumatic disruption in the lifes of nearly 300 little, innocent Catholic children?

Bishop Martino and the Scranton Diocese Catholic Schools Office, you state that this drastic decision to close two beloved Catholic schools at one time in the Pittston area is the result of a two-year study into the situation. But you and your staff are giving parents only THREE WEEKS to make a decison which may effect our children for the rest of their lives. It is not only unfair, it is dangerous and irresponsible.

Some parents may feel comfortable rushing out to register their children at the school which is their first choice after SJB and SMA. That is certainly understandable. Personally, my family resents being forced to not only make such a rash choice for my child without proper notice, but we also resent being pitted against other parents in a race to do what is best for our children.

We all face the rat race every day of our lives. That is life...that is unavoidable. But we refuse to run in this rat race that you have instigated. My child is uncertain about what school to attend should you go through with your plan. Our family is uncertain about what school is best for her. And we just cannot force ourselves to pick a school based on a one day Open House. We are sure that all four schools are fine schools for Catholic education. But we already had the PERFECT school for our child- St. John the Baptist. It is extremely traumatic to be forced to choose another unfamiliar school for our wonderful child who always puts such faith us us to do what is best for her.

We hope and pray that we am making the right decision. But it is the only decision we can make at this very uncertain time in our lives.

The above parent did not register her child during the forced registration. The child was registered at a later time at another Catholic school.

The registration on April 19, 2004 at Seton Catholic High School was a disaster by all accounts. It was crowded and, according to many parents, disorganized. There were tears and anger and, at one point when the full enrollment at Wyoming Area Catholic dictated that siblings could not attend the same school, an outburst from the crowd. A concession was made to allow the siblings to be in the same school.


FINAL NOTE

St. John the Baptist Elementary School in Pittston (1917- June 4,2004) and Saint Mary's Grade School in Avoca, PA (1919 - June 4,2004), closed on June 4, 2004 despite a long battle, which included a lawsuit filed by parents of SJB, to keep them opened.
Many of the students' parents have, as a result of their disillusionment with Bishop Joseph F. Martino, the Diocese of Scranton,and the Catholic Schools office, enrolled the children in public school.